Resist the Hindutva Appropriation of Swami Vivekananda

In this brief note, the author has expressed the need for resisting the practice of appropriation of religious figures like Vivekananda by the ruling Hindutva ideology. It is important for the secular intelligentsia, as the author argues, to engage with the multiple possibilities that an activist monk like Swami Vivekananda generated.

At a time when ‘Hindu icons’ are appropriated by the proponents of militant nationalism, it is not easy to invoke Swami Vivekananda. Furthermore, as the secular intelligentsia fails to engage with the realm of the spiritual, nothing seems to exist beyond the binaries of ‘right’ and ‘left’, ‘valorization’ and ‘condemnation’. However, the new generation growing up in these turbulent and confusing times ought to know that Swami Vivekananda—the action-oriented/university educated disciple of a remarkably simple and spiritually ecstatic Ramakrishna—was endowed with multiple possibilities. While in the age of colonial invasion he gave a distinctive identity to the resurgent nation with its ‘religious essence’ (not the aggression of fundamentalism, but the liberating soul as a guide line for managing the affairs of the world)’, he was also a saint with a hammer trying to transform Hinduism into an action plan for the upliftment of the subaltern. Even though he sought to create a ‘man making religion’ with ‘muscles of iron, nerves of steel and gigantic will’, like his master he was also a child of the feminine energy with a realization of the futility of male ego.


We know how the Marxists demystify the ‘opium’ called religion, and how, for the likes of Phule and Ambedkar, Hinduism with its caste-ridden hierarchical structure was seen to be a hindrance to the project of social emancipation. No wonder, these days in the radical/secular intellectual circuit we see a taboo on anything associated with Hinduism. Paradoxically, this taboo encourages militant Hindu nationalists to monopolize the entire discourse on Hinduism and its spiritual traditions. This must change; and liberal radicals including the Ambedkarites and Marxists must understand that a nuanced/creative/critical engagement with a monk like Swami Vivekananda is likely to generate new possibilities.

To retain our initiative towards free spirited and independent journalism we require your support |Pay Now

The intellectual hegemony( or a blend of Christianity and European sciences) that ‘benevolent’ colonial masters imposed on us seemed to have inspired a ‘renaissance man’ like Raja Rammohun Roy to fight idolatry and other obnoxious practices of Hinduism, and establish a highly sublime and intellectualized Brahmo Samaj causing a separation of the ‘intellectual’ from the ‘popular’. However, the arrival of Ramakrishna with his rural simplicity, spiritual ecstasy and catholicity was a turning point. With his folk wisdom and Vedantic metaphors, he could critique the new materialism that colonialism brought with it. As Vivekananda – a ‘university educated skeptic’— came closer to Ramakrishna, he came out of the temptation to fall into the trap of Brahmo elites, and became a ‘Hindu’ saint—but with a difference. In fact, the famous speech that the charismatic monk from the land of ‘oriental despotism’ delivered in the Chicago religious congress –a speech that reminded the world of the depths of the Upanishads— gave a new dynamism to the meaning of being a Hindu.

With his missionary zeal and celebration of ‘Practical Vedanta’, he spoke of the need to come out of the solitude of ‘forests, caves and mountains’, and enter into the actual realm of everyday action. True, Vedanta or the Upanishadic philosophy speaks of the all-pervading Brahma—the flow of eternal energy that passes through our finite/embodied existence; and the awakening of this energy enables us to conquer all sorts of fear and limitations of finitude. Practical Vedanta, for Vivekananda, is the ability to work with this boundless energy and excel as ‘cobblers, fishermen, traders and scholars’, and devote the fruits of our actions to the larger cause. Furthermore, his karmayoga—an innovative concretization of the Bhagavad Gita  further  added to his immense popularity amongst the youth and even the revolutionaries of that era. Possibly, his religious practice was a living critique of the Eurocentric notion of ‘other worldly’ Hinduism.

Broadly speaking, in post-Vivekananda era the practice of Hinduism took three important turns. Sri Aurobindo left the realm of active politics, took a complete spiritual turn, and with meditative solitude contemplated on the dynamics of human evolution through ‘ascent and integration’ of the physical, vital, mental and psychic stages of one’s being. Then, through his ‘experiments with truth’  Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi made the active realm of politics as his field of sadhana, and aroused the imagination of a spiritually enriched composite culture filled with the non-violent spirit of perpetual cross-religious conversations. But then, Hinduism also took a militant turn which celebrated the principle of hyper masculine nationalism based on the centrality of ‘Hindu identity’. In fact, with Savarkar and Golwalkar Hinduism as a majoritarian doctrine became a weapon for unifying the ‘Hindu race’ by minimizing the influence of ‘alien intruders’. No wonder, violence was its natural sub-text.

As history poses a challenge before us in this hour of darkness, we need to engage with Vivekananda’s ‘Practical Vedanta’ and Gandhi’s dialogic Hinduism, enrich secularism as symmetrical pluralism through the ecstasy of spiritual oneness, and fight Hindutva or for that matter, any other fundamentalist force in the domain of politics and culture.

Prof. Avijit Pathak teaches at the Centre for the Study of Social Systems, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.

Now that you are here...
From bottled water to oxygen cans, not even the basics are free in a market-driven world. Why then, do we take free and independent journalism for granted? We find ourselves at a time when more people like you, are reading and coming out in support of The New Leam’s independent, in-depth and throughly issue based journalism than ever before. From grassroot stories and field-reports, to in-depth analysis of the pertinent political issues of our times, to news on gender, culture and educational issues- The New Leam has been dedicated to bringing out stories that speak out the soul of India and take you beyond the propaganda-filled corridors of mainstream journalism in India. We have made an important choice of keeping our journalism free of vested political interests, commercial funding and influence of partisan stakeholders, so that we can bring forward news and stories based on facts and provide a platform where readers can find information with integrity and a journalism premised on honesty. 

Your support to The New Leam is your contribution towards giving a voice to the voiceless, going to the depths of issues that others shy away from and rigorously illuminating the flame of criticality and courage in dark times. We hope that you will come forward to support The New Leam today so that we can keep delivering quality-independent journalism to you and inform public opinion in the right direction. No matter how big or small your contribution may be, it is tremendously important. It takes only a moment, Support The New Leam now!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *